Understanding the Tainos’ Impressions of Columbus

Loading...

From the course by The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill

Reasoning Across the Disciplines

13 оценки

The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill

Reasoning Across the Disciplines

13 оценки

Critical reasoning skills are a key success factor for students entering their first year of college. They must be able to think logically and form arguments. This course, designed with incoming college freshmen in mind but open to anyone, provides an essential grounding in critical reasoning skills. Faculty from multiple disciplines at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill offer guidance on applying critical thinking skills in the context of specific disciplines. By developing these skills, students will learn more, enjoy their courses more, and experience greater academic success. This course will help you understand what critical thinking skills are and why they're so important. You will also learn how critical thinking skills vary across disciplines, as well as see them applied across several fields, including, chemistry, history, psychology, law, English, and American Studies. You will develop your own critical thinking skills by working through scenarios or problems posed by scholars across these fields, and you will better understand how your college courses will differ from your earlier education.

From the lesson

Think Like an Historian

In this module, you'll learn about critical thinking and history from Kathleen DuVal.

Turning the World Upside Down3:26

Understanding Columbus’s Impressions of the Tainos8:04

Understanding the Tainos’ Impressions of Columbus4:19

Meet the Instructors

Dr. Ram Neta
Professor
Philosophy

So far, in reading the letter from Columbus that he wrote in 1493.

We've learned a lot about what he thought the people who sent him, Ferdinand and

Isabella, wanted to hear.

And what he thought about the things that he saw.

But we'd also like to use this letter to learn about the people that

he met in the Americas, the Tainos.

To do this, to use a European source to understand something about

American Indians who didn't write the source themselves.

We are going to use the tools of what's called ethnohistory.

Ethnohistory combines the ways that historians use to understand

the past with archaeology, with oral history, with later accounts.

And with very close readings of sources like this Columbus letter.

That all together may give us clues into the lives and

the thoughts of people who didn't write down what they were doing and thinking.

So if you think about the Columbus letter, we have to use it,

with all of its biases, to try to understand something about other people.

As we read this excerpt from the letter together.

I want you to imagine the arrival of Columbus and

his men as the Tainos might have seen it.

>> Of all them I took possession on behalf of their Highnesses with oral proclamation

and the royal banner flying, and nobody contradicted.

>> When Columbus says oral proclamation, probably what he did was describe for

the Tainos a quick version of the European view of the world That God is in charge.

There's one God.

Underneath God are monarchs, including Ferdinand and Isabella.

And below the monarchs are Europeans.

And he might have mentioned, below the Europeans might be you, the Tainos.

As the Tainos listened to this and watched the royal banner, the flag flying,

as Columbus says.

One thing to remember is he's talking in Spanish.

So they actually have no idea what he's saying.

Probably from his tone and

from the flying flag they could infer that this was a ceremony.

That he was saying something that he thought was important.

There's pretty much no way that they understood the word, possession,

in the same way that Columbus meant it.

To Columbus, he was establishing his monarch's possession,

ownership, of this island.

You can believe the Tainos did not think of it that way.

Now, you do this one.

I'm going to put up another excerpt.

And I want you to keep in mind Columbus's motivations,

the way we talked about them earlier.

And how his motivations might have colored his interpretations of the Taínos.

And then, let me also tell you a fact about the Taínos.

They had a very long history of trade with other islands.

So they were not isolated.

They had small boats that would go back and forth to the mainland and

other islands.

When they see Columbus, Columbus is in a different kind of boat, and

looks different in some ways.

But he's not all together alien to them.

>> Anything they own, all you have to do is ask for it and they never say no.

But give themselves with it and show so

much love that they would give their hearts.

And whether they are wanting something valuable or of little value,

they are satisfied with any little thing you give them in exchange.

I forbade my men to give them anything so trashy as pieces of broken bowls,

or broken glass, or bits of needles.

Although, when they did get them,

they held them like the finest jewels in the world.

And there was one sailor who for a needle got gold weighing two and

a half castellanos.

And there were other sailors who, for

other, less valuable things, got much more.

>> Try to figure out what the Tainos were doing and

thinking is harder than trying to figure out what Columbus was doing and thinking.

Because even though he presents his letter in a certain way,

because he's writing to the king and queen.

He's writing in the Tainos aren't.

But we, as historians, do the best we can to try to combine letters like this

one with other kinds of evidence to try to figure out what the Tainos were thinking.

So in conclusion, history is about solving puzzles of the past.

Using evidence and applying our own analytical skills to try and

figure out those puzzles.

And then conveying those interpretations through oral and written communication.

You'll do all these things in class here in Chapel Hill, and

we can't wait to see you.

Ознакомьтесь с нашим каталогом

Присоединяйтесь бесплатно и получайте персонализированные рекомендации, обновления и предложения.

Coursera делает лучшее в мире образование доступным каждому, предлагая онлайн-курсы от ведущих университетов и организаций.

© Coursera Inc., 2018 Все права защищены.

Загрузить из App Store

Загрузить в Google Play