Now i feel confident about pursuing machine learning courses in the future as I have learned most of the mathematics which will be helpful in building the base for machine learning, data science.
This is one hell of an inspiring course that demystified the difficult concepts and math behind PCA. Excellent instructors in imparting the these knowledge with easy-to-understand illustrations.
автор: Michael-John B•
If I could give it negative stars I would.
автор: Mohamed S•
topics are poorly explained and confusing
автор: Heinz D•
Good and motivating lecturer with decent language, thank you! Challenging course but the relief at the end is great. I'd prefer if the lecturer wouldn't write his texts to the very border of the board because if I'm taking screenshots in PiP mode, the window's controls (close window, play, return to normal video mode) are overlapping.
Week 1: Pre-course survey contains the questions of rather a post-course survey. The lab / programming assignment contains misleading code segments and incomplete explanations.
Week 2: Quiz 'General inner products', dealing with 3-dimensional inner products is very challenging as the lecture only went - in an extreme hurry - through 2-dimensional examples.
Week 3: Programming Assignment contains misleading code segments / comments (e.g. contradiction concerning return variable in project_1d()).
Week 4: Video 'Problem setting and PCA objective' -> Download Link to the PCA book chapter goes to Nirvana.
автор: Israel J L•
Great course !! Definitely it's an intermediate course so if you don't have a college level in lineal algebra and calculus you'll struggle with the videos and the notebooks (besides you need basic level programing in python and numpy)
The videos are kinda hard but it seems that Marc it's a great mathematician and also he shares a great e-book written by him that has everything seen in the course and more, so with this you can get all the knowledge need it to understand PCA.
I don't understand why it's only 4 stars rated; again if you want to learn linear algebra and calculus, this is not the place... you need to have the needed level to suceed.
автор: Tze C L•
This third and final course in the Mathematics for Machine Learning specialization is the most challenging of them all. This course focuses on deriving the PCA algorithm from scratch. As such, this course introduces you to more abstract topics of Linear Algebra that is not covered by the earlier courses in this specialization.
To follow along in this course, you need the accompanying text book "Mathematics for Machine Learning" written by the instructor himself. This text book is free to download in PDF format (website given in the course). This text book alone is worth the 5 stars, IMHO.
автор: Frank N•
This is a great course. However, the prerequisites for this course should be more specific. It gets frustrating to realise that you cannot answer a question because you lack certain background knowledge.
In general, it is a great course. You would finish this course with a sense of fulfillment after completing all those challenging assignments. Thank you for this priceless knowledge!
автор: Veeramani. S•
Good Explanation. Very helpful for learning an application of mathematics through this course
автор: Makozz Q•
I'd like to say thanks to everyone who has made this learning experience possible.
Thank you, Marc. Your explanations combined with the book "Mathematics for Machine Learning" have come really handy.
It has been an amazing journey to see how linear algebra marries multivariate calculus to give birth to to PCA.
Being a linguist, I must admit I'm quite new to Python and the domain of machine learning. It would be great if you could add some polishing touches to the programming assignments, especially the one in Week 4 (PCA): waiting for a long time until the system finishes crunching the code was quite a slow experience. If that has to do with a student's sloppy code, please add some recommendations inside the assignment on how to avoid this trap. If that is caused by some technical issues on the server side, please take a moment to look at this.
That you have added the Python tutorial is really helpful. Could you also consider updating it with some details on how to sort eigenvectors and eigenvalues to collect these into a covariance matrix. This piece was mighty tough.
Thank you once again. Keep on!
автор: Henry N•
Overall this was a pretty good course - some other reviews comment on how some things are glossed over in the videos but you'll get the most out of it if the other courses in the specialisation are fresh in your mind (e.g. you'll have to know about eigenvectors/eigenvalues, Gaussian elimination, derivatives and the chain rule etc. as these are referred to and used but not explained in detail - but these are covered in the first 2 courses). The main problem is with the assignments - for some weeks there's not enough guidance about what the functions should be returning, so these should be better documented; the other issue is that some of the code that we are not required to edit doesn't actually work - for instance, my implementation of PCA passed the grader but the visualisations in the week 4 notebook didn't work.
автор: Andrea V•
This course is hard, and contains a lot of mathematical derivations and concepts that might be overwhelming for somebody not completely fresh in maths. Nevertheless, it offers a good balance between rigour and practical application, and if some lectures turn out to be too complicated, there's always the chance to deepen the matter more quitely using the course material or online resources. I think that the course would have benefited from a more aneddoctical approach at times: for instance restating in english what the general purpose of PCA is, could help the less mathematically inclined to better seize the idea. But I know this is not always easy to do.
автор: Arka S•
Frankly, after the high of the first two courses of this specialisation, this one was a low. Instruction was typical of most Universities; heavily analytical and monotonous. This was not a proper way, especially for such a complicated (for beginners) topic like PCA. This course could've been executed in a much better way.
Still a lot of insight is there to be gained, and I learnt quite a few things. The simplification of the cost (or loss) function was explained well, and I had quite a few 'Aha!' moments in this course as well (in Weeks 3 and 4), albeit not as much as I did in the first two courses (Lin Alg and Multivariate Calc).
автор: Ruarob T•
Make sure you have time and be ready for python code debug. If you are just an average programmer with limited python exposure like me. It will take you a day to complete the programming assignment.
Note: the assignment and class VDO seems a distant - google a lot during the assignment/quiz
Note: Programming has little clue - personally, I think I spend so much time on programming (distracting me away from going back to Math review)
автор: Stanislav B•
Rather difficult course and will probably reqire to watch additional video-explanations on YouTube as well as studing math notation, etc. Otherwise, helpfull and comprehensive.
автор: Berkay E•
-Some of the contents are not clear.
+It gets great intuition for new learners in machine learning.
автор: sairavikanth t•
Lot of Math. Couldn't get proper intuition regarding PCA, was lost in understanding math equations
автор: Jessica P•
I agree with the others. Course didn't merge well with the 1st two which were perfect!
автор: Clara M L•
Not as good as the other two courses but still very intuitive
автор: Shilin G•
Not as good as previous two courses. I understand it is an intermediate course, but still, the video does not help you do the quiz, e.g. the video uses 2x2 matrices for example while quiz is mainly about 3x3 - then why not include a 3x3 example? Programming assignment is not clear either, some places you have to change the shape of matrix but it is not explained why this is necessary (and actually it is not). A lot of room for improvement here.
автор: Patrick G•
Very challenging course in terms of computing ; one have to always go to the forum which is very active and function like StackOverFlow. You must have somme skills in PYthon, an intermediate level in matrix algebra and deserve a high amount of time and effort to do the assignments but at the end you get a good comprehension of PCA algorithm.
автор: Ustinov A•
Unfortunately, mistakes in grader and a bad python environment spoilt the impression. I lose hours because of it during 1, 2 and 4 week. It's not enough exercises last week. You should add more examples for every step of PCA for better understanding.
автор: Yougui Q•
The course is relatively harder than the other two courses in this specialization. The lecturer didn't provide understandable examples while demonstrating the concepts. The grader for Python assignments didn't function well either.
автор: D. H•
The system is problematic, just take a look those complains in the forum. I also got very frustrated from the last assignment.
автор: Yiqing W•
The teaching is good but some programming assignment is not so good
автор: Narongdej S•
Confusing for beginners; the explanations are too abrupt
автор: David S•
Of the ten or so courses that I have completed on coursera and other platforms, this one has been the most poorly taught. Usually I give four or five stars. This course gets two, which I feel is charitable.
A few examples of why I rated this course so poorly come to mind
· Instead of video lectures students are repeatedly sent to Wikipedia or similar
· The lecturer’s 417-page text was available, but without worked examples and no reference between lecture material and text
· Examples on the videos often skipped steps
· Often the videos did not have enough information to do the quizzes
· The instructor has not been on the discussion forum for 16 months
· Uninspiring assignments (and laughably low estimated times to complete)
· Intermediate level Python is required, but not mentioned as a prerequisite
I know that ‘style’ is subjective, but the institution (Imperial College London) and Coursera really should have given the lecturer some training on how to appear to enjoy teaching. Personally I would not want to attend this school for fear of being stuck with this lecturer for a semester.
The negativity of this review is unfortunate since Principal Component Analysis is an important and popular concept in statistics, math and machine learning. I hope this course is replaced in the near future. In the meantime solid on-line resources teaching the same material are available. Unfortunately I needed those resources – and an outside tutor – to pass this course.